Skip to main content

What to Do About a Bad Review

The first bad review feels personal, because it is. Someone has written something unfair about work you care about, in public, where your customers and your family can read it. The instinct to correct the record is completely human and it is almost always the wrong move. Here is how to respond to negative reviews in a way that actually works, including the part most advice skips: what to do when the review is simply not true.

24h
a reasonable target to reply, after you have stopped being angry
20+
people who will read your reply for every one who wrote the review
Genuine
experience is the standard Google applies to reviews

Who the reply is really for

The reviewer has already formed their opinion and is unlikely to change it. Everyone else has not. A prospect comparing three businesses reads the worst review first, then reads your reply, and makes a judgement about what happens when something goes wrong with you.

That reframes the whole exercise. You are not arguing. You are demonstrating, to an audience, how your business behaves under criticism. A calm, specific reply to a one star review regularly does more for conversion than the four and five star reviews above it, because it is the only evidence anyone has about the bad day.

What Google advises

Google publishes guidance on replying to reviews: keep replies professional, polite and concise, address the reviewer by name, respond promptly, address the specific feedback rather than sending a generic thank you, avoid using replies for promotions, and handle negative reviews constructively by acknowledging the concern and offering to resolve it privately.

Google also frames reviews as needing to reflect a genuine experience, and values both positive and negative ones as trustworthy indicators. That last point matters: a profile with only perfect reviews reads as suspicious, and a few critical ones handled well make the good ones believable.

A reply that works

Four parts, in this order, and short.

Acknowledge what they experienced. Not an admission of fault, an acknowledgement that their experience was not what you intend. Thank you for telling us, this is not the experience we want people to have.

Be specific enough to prove you read it. Reference the actual issue. A generic reply signals that nobody looked, which confirms the complaint.

Say what you did or will do. One concrete sentence. We have changed how we confirm appointment times. This is the sentence the next twenty readers are actually looking for.

Move it offline. Give a direct way to reach a person who can fix it. Google recommends offering private resolution, and it also ends the public thread, which serves you.

What to leave out: the full story from your side, their account history, anything defensive, anything sarcastic, and any suggestion they are lying. Every one of those reads badly to a stranger no matter how justified it is.

When the review is unfair or false

They were never a customer

Reviews are supposed to reflect a genuine experience. If someone has never dealt with you, that is a policy violation you can flag for removal. Do it, and reply publicly in the meantime with a neutral note that you have no record of this person as a customer and would like to understand the situation.

It is a competitor or a personal grievance

Same route: flag it, keep the reply factual and unemotional. Naming and accusing publicly makes you look worse than the review does, even when you are right.

It contains prohibited content

Abuse, personal information, content unrelated to your business. These are reportable. Flag and wait rather than engaging with the content.

It is accurate and you had a bad day

Then the honest reply is the strongest one available to you. Owning a mistake in public, briefly and without excuses, is unusual enough that people remember it.

Set expectations on removal: reviews that are simply unflattering but honest will stay, and no service that promises to delete them can deliver that. Flagging works for policy violations, not for disagreement.

Never do these

Do not offer anything in exchange for changing or removing it. Google prohibits offering payment, discounts or free goods in exchange for posting, revising or removing a review. It is also the kind of thing that ends up quoted in a follow up review.

Do not respond the same hour. Wait until you are not angry. Write the reply you want to send, do not send it, and rewrite it the next morning at a third of the length.

Do not counter with fake positives. Beyond the platform rules, in Canada a representation that is false or misleading in a material respect falls under the Competition Act, which the Competition Bureau assesses on the general impression as well as the literal meaning.

The real defence is volume

One bad review among six is a crisis. One among ninety is a rounding error that makes the profile look human. The single most effective thing you can do about bad reviews is to have a steady habit of collecting genuine ones, which is covered in how to get more Google reviews.

Businesses that only think about reviews when a bad one arrives are always in a weak position. Businesses collecting two or three a month are never more than a few weeks from burying one.

Frequently asked questions

Can I get a bad review removed?

Only if it violates Google policies, such as not reflecting a genuine experience or containing prohibited content. Flag it through your profile. Honest negative feedback stays.

Should I reply to every review?

Google recommends replying, and it is worth doing for negatives especially. For positives a short specific thank you is plenty, and a generic one adds nothing.

How fast should I reply?

Promptly, which for most businesses means within a day. Fast enough to look attentive, slow enough that you are calm.

Does a bad review hurt my ranking?

Reviews sit within prominence and Google says more reviews and positive ratings can help. A single negative among many is not a ranking event. A pattern of them is a business problem before it is a ranking one.

Should I ask the customer to remove it after fixing the problem?

You can mention that they are welcome to update it if they feel differently. Do not pressure, do not offer anything, and accept the answer either way.

Reviews piling up unanswered? Book a free consultation and we will set up replies and a steady flow of new reviews so one bad day stops defining your listing.

Technocure Digital Solutions

Technocure Team

Technocure Digital Solutions is a bilingual digital agency specializing in website design, SEO and Google Ads. We have served clients worldwide since 2012 and have been based in Montreal since 2020. More about us.

Continue reading
Clear Filters

Getting Your Online Store Ready for Black Friday

Black Friday is November 27 this year. Seventeen days to fix the things that quietly cost you sales on the busiest weekend of the year.

How to Show Up for Near Me Searches

You cannot optimise for the phrase near me, and businesses waste money trying. What Google is actually doing with those searches, and what genuinely affects the result.